First! (in 2013)
I'm still in LotRO on Elendilmir (guild is Thirsty Travelers). Me and some friends play Mondays and another couple of nights a week.
I still enjoy it. The world is getting larger and larger all the time.
Mounted combat is pretty dang fun (except the occasional rubberbanding problem).
With skirmishes and all of the level-adjustable instances and the handful of raids... never bored.
Still a fun casual game for me and recently got an old gaming buddy involved in it so some friends all rolled up new toons and are taking a walk through all the content again (a lot of which has been reworked by Turbine).
At any rate... I'll drop by next year and see if this gets a followup! (hehe)