First i'm going +1 for claymore and Ergo proxy though Ergo proxy will confuse you for a little... least it did me.
I had to keep a list of stuff I've watched : http://www.anime-planet.com/users/Taoden/anime
you can chose a filter and search.. might find some stuff maybe. Let me know if the link doesn't work.
As for TPB, kinda a pita anymore. Check out BakaBT, They deal mostly with anime, rec's suggestions etc forums there are wonderful.
Also going to Echo Tivia's post. It can be a pain to keep up with fansub groups etc but BakaBT does a good job of listing stuff.
Hope this helps you a little.