TheSafehouse



He hoped and prayed that there wasn't an afterlife. Then he realized there was a contradiction involved here and merely hoped that there wasn't an afterlife. -Douglas Adams (Hitch Hikers Guide)




Safehouse Forums



Safehouse Site Info



 

The end is nigh


 

 

 







Register FAQ Members List Calendar Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Darkefang
Darkefang is offline
Formerly Known as Hordur... Hodru... Hodurbear

Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Southern Indiana


Darkefang's Avatar

 
Ignoring hearts and minds for explosions
Reply With Quote   #1

Since the beginning of the war in Iraq, a major criticism of the press coverage has been that it focuses entirely on the violence and ignores all the positive achievements accomplished by US forces. Car bombs and shootings grab headlines while stories about the opening of new schools and hospitals are relegated to the trash bin.

Michael Fumento, one of those critics, seems to have gained a new insight into the press' coverage in Iraq:

SPOILER:
Is the MSM to blame for blocking good news from the wars?

By Michael Fumento

I personally have repeatedly scored the MSM for wanting to write about nothing but The Car Bomb of the Day and ignoring hearts-and-minds projects. Now I realize that while the MSM still deserve scorn, perhaps things aren't quite as black and white as I thought. In preparing my article on my recent embed that will be appearing in next week's Weekly Standard I sought to get information on such projects in the Zabul Region of Afghanistan directly from the Provincial Reconstruction Team or PRT. Zabul's PRT is run by the Air Force. Here's what transpired:

Mike,

Can you send me a few questions and the angle you're leaning toward for your story? From there, I can set up an interview with the PRT commander or our lead civil affairs person. Thanks!

Bob

Capt. Bob Everdeen
Commander's Exec
PRT Qalat, Afghanistan
I did so, then said the responses could be by e-mail or phone, whichever was easiest for them. I calculated it would take 20 minutes or less for them to provide a response by either means. Days went by. Now here's the rest of the correspondence:

Bob,

I've learned what I can about PRT Zabul from the Internet, but it would be a lot better to get the highlights from your people. That said, with or without I've got to turn this piece in tomorrow.

Best,
Mike
Mike,

Sorry about the delayed response; unfortunately, I will not be able to get you information this time. Thank you.

Bob
Dear Cpt. Everdeen:

So much for military complaints that the media only focus on explosions and
killings while ignoring hearts and minds projects. It appears the mainstream
media aren't as blameworthy in this regard as I thought. Unconventional wars
are won or lost as much in the media as on the battlefield; it's unfortunate
that the Air Force apparently doesn't realize that. As someone who sees
this war as something to be won, I will be writing about this.

Sincerely,
Michael Fumento
And so I have.


Every other segment of the military has suffered from understaffing. I guess the public relations departments are similarly understaffed. At the risk of sounding cliche, I guess Halliburton doesn't offer media relations services.



-"Guns don't kill people, but they sure help."

Don't click here.
Lenilya
Lenilya is offline
Veteran

Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Seattle


Lenilya's Avatar

 
Re: Ignoring hearts and minds for explosions
Reply With Quote   #2

I allways found it odd that they didn't broadcast some of the footage we saw on AFN (Armed-forces network) while I was on deployment- there was a lot of 'human intrest' stories on everything from a musical band that played its first legal concert in however many years, to a girl being accepted into a school that had been, up to that point, illegal for girls to attend.

Odd.


Chromite
Chromite is offline
Veteran

Join Date: May 1999


Chromite's Avatar

 
Re: Ignoring hearts and minds for explosions
Reply With Quote   #3

I think many people now try to get the non-MSM info from blogs. Unfortunately that recent ban on military blogging might hinder this :-/

If you want to read a really good site check out Michael Yon's Online Magazine. http://www.michaelyon-online.com/

Some really good entries on there.





Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump







 
All times are GMT -7. The time now is 04:01 AM.
All posts are
© Copyright 2004-2006 The Safehouse Network